Springe direkt zu Inhalt

Ronja Hildebrandt M.A.


Ancient Philosophy and History of Ancient Science (APhil/HistAS)

Antike Philosophie

10/2018 – 09/2020
Wissenschaftliche Mitarbeiterin, Lehrstuhl für Philosophie der Antike und Gegenwart, Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin

10/2014 – 07/2020
Promotionsstudentin, gefördert durch die Research Training Group Philosophy, Science and the Sciences

11/2017 – 02/2018
Visiting Research Collaborator, Princeton University

10/2016 – 01/2017
Visiting Research Collaborator, Princeton University

10/2011 – 03/2015
Master of Arts in Philosophie, Humboldt-University zu Berlin

09/2012 – 02/2013
Erasmus Mundus Stipendiatin, University of Nottingham

10/2009 – 09/2011
Bachelor of Arts in Philosophie, Philipps-Universität Marburg

Why Philosophy? Aristotle's Defense of Philosophy in the Protrepticus

In my dissertation project, I have pursued the question of how Aristotle defends philosophy against critics such as his contemporary Isocrates. I believe that such a study is both historically and systematically interesting. It is historically interesting because it sheds light on how Aristotle positioned himself against his opponents in the question of what philosophy is and why we should study it. Furthermore, it is systematically interesting because views similar to Isocrates’ still linger on today, even if maybe not first and foremost among philosophers: namely views along the line that philosophy should prepare for the practical life and that philosophy as Plato or Aristotle taught it is hardly useful for this life. Can Aristotle be a guide to a response to such critics?

The project has the following three parts: A first part introduces Isocrates’ criticism against the way Aristotle (and others) understood and valued philosophy. In the second part of my dissertation, I try to determine what Aristotle understands as philosophy – because if we want to understand why and how Aristotle defends “philosophy”, we first need to understand what he means by this term. Finally, I discuss Aristotle’s arguments in defence of philosophy. My focus is on arguments from Aristotle’s Protrepticus since this work was designed as a defence of and an encouragement towards philosophy. In the Protrepticus, we find arguments for the intrinsic and the extrinsic value of philosophy, and I discuss both kinds of arguments.

What Is Philosophy in the Protrepticus? In: Aristotle’s Lost Works. Ed. by António Pedro Mesquita and Christopher Shields (forthcoming with De Gruyter)